Survivors’ Call to Reform
the Archdiocese of Boston
The following is a document prepared by an unaffiliated group
of Greater Boston survivors. We present it here to stimulate awareness
of the continuing need for survivor justice and discussion of meaningful
reform. VOTF has not taken a position on the specific actions within
the document.
In
early July, 2003, more than twenty survivors came together
to answer
the question, “What do we want
the Church to do?” Through meetings, e-mails and countless conversations
we reached consensus and produced the preceding document. We
hope that Bishop O’Malley and other members of the Church hierarch
will use this document, informed by our horrific experiences,
to create a safer environment that can begin to truly honor and
protect the sacredness of all children and adults. If you would
like more information, please contact Kathy Dwyer, wolfkmd@aol.com,
Dale Walsh, dalewalsh@aol.com,or Ann Hagan Webb, annhaganwebb@yahoo.com.
ACCOUNTABILITY & RESPONSIBILITY:
REFORM ACTION: The Church hierarchy will admit to their culpability and
guilt in knowingly moving pedophile priests from parish to parish,
resulting in the additional abuse of countless children and adults.
How
it Will be Observable
-
The
Church will publicly and in writing state that they were responsible
for the abuse of countless children and adults and that the
abuse was not the fault of the victims, and that the shame
belongs only to those who did the abuse and those who covered
it up.
-
The
Church will likewise acknowledge responsibility for the countless
secondary victims of abuse.
-
The
Church will release any and all orders, both past and present
that have required survivors to be silent and will not require
silence in future cases.
-
Members
of the hierarchy, priests, Church employees and volunteers
will attend yearly training offered by outside professionals
on the State Mandatory Reporting Laws.
-
Members
of the hierarchy, priests, Church employees and volunteers
will attend yearly training offered by outside professionals
on power dynamics and the ways that power can be used to do
good or to do harm.
-
Members
of the hierarchy, priests, Church employees and volunteers
will attend yearly child abuse trainings offered by outside
professionals.
-
The
Church will establish and implement a policy that insures that
the mandatory reporting requirements are being followed.
-
The
Church will offer trainings to parishes, Catholic schools and
other Church-run organizations on ways to protect and empower
both children and adults.
-
The
Church will consistently speak out against the abuse of children
and adults.
-
The
Church will provide resources in their weekly bulletins for
those people and their families who have been and/or who are
being abused.
-
The
Church will take perpetrators and anyone who has knowingly
failed to report suspected abuse of children or adults off
their payroll.
SAFETY:
REFORM ACTION 1: The Church will create an environment of safety for children,
adults and all who enter.
How
it Will be Observable
-
Candidates
for seminary, as well as potential Church employees and volunteers
will
be put
through extensive screenings, modeled after other agencies
that are also mandated reporters. This will include yearly
CORI checks.
-
Current
bishops, priests, Church employees and volunteers will submit
to CORI checks.
-
No
person with a history of abusive behavior will be allowed to
work for the Church.
-
No
cardinal, bishop, priest, Church employee or volunteer will
be alone with a child.
-
All people
who are receiving pastoral counseling will first receive
a document
that outlines
their rights and responsibilities and what they should and
should not expect from the person providing the pastoral counseling. Included
in this document will be the fact that the person that is providing
the counseling is a Mandated Reporter of abuse.
-
When
children or adolescents are receiving pastoral counseling they
and their parents or guardians will be given a similar document.
-
All cardinals,
bishops, priests, Church employees and volunteers will engage
in an
internal
process to address power dynamics specifically related to their
own positions. The
goal of this process will be for participants to understand
power dynamics, how power was and is abused, and ways to use
it in
positive and healing ways.
-
The
Church will require all convicted sex offenders to register
as such and will support notification of the public as a way
to increase the safety of all children, regardless of their
religion.
-
The Church
will create its own “Registry” of credible allegations of abuse by a clergy,
Church employee or volunteer, as determined by an Independent
Review Board. When a case has been settled, names of the accused
will be listed in the “Registry,” and the Church will yearly
inform the laity how to access the information.
REFORM ACTION 2: The Church will create its own supervised homes or institutions
whereby abusive clergy can live out their lifetime.
How
it Will be Observable
-
The
Church will only allow convicted or self-disclosed abusive
clergy to be part of their Church if they, upon completion
of their sentence or self-disclosure, agree to go to one of
these homes or institutions.
-
The
Church will monitor all residents of such a home/institution.
-
The
Church will not allow any resident to go anywhere outside the
home/institution without the accompaniment of a non-offending
companion who is knowledgeable in the behaviors of sexual crimes.
-
The
Church will not allow any resident to be around any children.
-
The
Church will not allow any resident to offer pastoral support
to any adult.
-
The
Church, with the help of survivors and professional who work
with people who sexually abused children and adults, will develop
policies that will decrease the risk of abuse.
INDEPENDENT
OUTREACH & ADVOCACY
These
recommendations are in no way meant to replace The Office for
Pastoral Support and Outreach but rather are meant to meet
the needs of those survivors who would find it too painful
and/or triggering to seek support from an office established
by the Church.
REFORM ACTION 1: An Independent Outreach and Advocacy Program will be implemented.
How
it Will be Observable
· The
Church will become a “third party payer.”
· No
survivor will have to go to the Church for financial assistance.
· The
Church will agree to an outside agency determining eligibility,
not unlike mental health centers determine the need for counseling
and notify the insurance company. (Note: Susan Gallagher and
others have been working diligently on this and have major outside
agencies involved and supportive. This initiative supports their
recommendations.)
· The
Church will reimburse survivor’s money already spent on therapy
and other survivor-related expenses, including medications prescribed
to support their healing process.
· The
Church will pay for therapy for all victims (including those
who had cases and have already settled) for as long as they need
it.
· The
Church will pay for therapy for secondary victims, including,
but not limited to, parents, siblings and significant others.
· The
Church will not use survivor’s records against them.
· The
Church will pay for medical costs for medical conditions associated
with the abuse.
· The
Church will pay for in-patient treatment for survivors when necessary.
REFORM ACTION 2: The Church will
give a lump sum of money to fund a healing center.
How
it Will be Observable
-
The
Church will set up an endowment to be used to fund a healing
center for survivors of clergy abuse.
-
The
Church’s only role will be funding this healing center.
-
Church
hierarchy will acknowledge and defer to an outside Board of
Directors named by survivors and made up of survivors and people
from the professional trauma community.
-
Church
hierarchy will recognize and respect the power of the Board
to hire and fire.
LEGISLATIVE & LEGAL:
REFROM
ACTION 1: Call
for repeal of Statute of Limitations.
How
it Will be Observable
-
The
Church hierarchy will support the repeal of the Statue of Limitations.
-
The
Church hierarchy will, through their media outlets, Church
bulletins and the pulpit, clearly state that the Archdiocese
of Boston supports the repeal of the Statue of Limitations.
REFORM ACTION 2: Civil and criminal cases will be treated with ethics and
morality.
How
it Will be Observable
-
The
Church will release all personnel files of accused priests,
Church employees and volunteers.
-
The
Church hierarchy and their lawyers will immediately stop “hard
ball” tactics such as blaming the abuse on parents, victims
and/or other people, places or things (i.e., Gays, the 60’s,
the media).
-
They
will not bring in outside “experts,” such as Elizabeth Loftus,
to discredit survivors.
-
They
will not bring in survivor behaviors to manipulate the responsibility
for the abuse.
REFORM ACTION 3: Settle cases, providing that people want to settle the cases,
without intimidation.
How
it Will be Observable
-
Church
hierarchy and their lawyers will not demand survivor’s silence
in any settlement.
-
Church
hierarchy and their lawyers will not pressure, demean or “guilt trip” a survivor
to settle (i.e., survivors will not be told that if they do not
settle no one will get anything. Survivors are individuals and
what teach may want in a settlement may vary. Each should
be allowed their own process to the extent their case allows
it.)
|