Please
send comments to leaderpub@votf.org
In the Vineyard "This
is what the Holy One asks of you: only this, to act justly,
No doubt there are as many ways to note an anniversary as there are candles on some of our cakes. Once again, VOTF chooses words and action to "speak" for us as we rededicate ourselves to our shared mission and goals and as we continue to draw Catholics into the conversation about our faith and its future in the Roman Catholic Church. If you have been following our progress on the website, in the regular editions of In the Vineyard and in the media, you already know the work that is being done and the work that lies ahead. Susan Troy and the National Prayerful Voice team she leads, remind us regularly of the place of spirituality in all that we say and do. (See the Liturgy of Rededication on our website. http://www.votf.org/Prayerful_Voice/pvevents.html) Recently, Susan quoted Ronald Rolheiser, author of The Holy Longing: The Search for a Christian Spirituality, "Spirituality is not a private search for what is highest in oneself but a communal search for the face of God. What shapes our actions is our spirituality." As our growing community searches for the face of God, we do so in a variety of ways - many of these focus on hearing each other and are well documented in the stream of reports from our 150 affiliates across the U.S. and, most recently, Canada. The written word is another of our efforts toward Rolheiser's "communal search." To progress this ambition, In the Vineyard is introducing some new columns with this issue. Our first Parish "Best Practices" piece appears; VOTF member Tom Smith has written a book review (other recommended reading appears on our website at Prayerful Voice http://www.votf.org/Prayerful_Voice/readings.html); VOTF member Mary Hogan begins a "Say What?" column that will "take on" some of the words we use in our faith journey, how we use them, and where they come from; Anne Murphy introduces a Q&A - we hope readers will challenge us! We also introduce the VOTF National office staff, whose work pretty much defines the how of what VOTF does. Were it not for our staff, volunteers, parish voices and affiliates, officers and working groups, VOTF would just be another great idea. Looking back, of course, is part of any anniversary so we have reprinted the whole text of our Convocation statement delivered to Cardinal Law on March 9, 2002, along with a few reflections by those in attendance. Right now, however, we begin where we began and welcome the first voice of Voice of the Faithful, our founder Dr. Jim Muller. Peggie L. Thorp, Ed.
VOTF president Jim Post looks back with gratitude on a year well spent. From Jim Post, President of VOTFThis Spirit-ed YearWhat a grace it is to be marking the first anniversary of Voice of the Faithful. Our actual date of birth is still debated by the founders, but there is no doubt that we first introduced ourselves to the public on March 9, 2002. On that day, a group of pioneer women (and three men) from Wellesley, MA - each wearing red - attended the archdiocesan convocation in the name of "Voice of the Faithful." It did not take very long for our pioneers to make an impression on the thousands in attendance that day. They were intelligent, articulate, and identifiable in their red outfits. They spoke of shame, sin, and scandal. They called for justice, awareness, and commitment to correcting a system that had failed so many innocent children. They asked the archbishop cardinal to listen and to act. They were angry and they said so. Looking back on the year that has passed, I think none of us could have imagined the incredible experience that VOTF has become. Our goals on that convocation day in March were clear: support those who have been abused; support priests of integrity; and shape structural change within the Church. These are the same goals we seek to achieve today. And we are making progress. VOTF has captured the imagination of lay Catholics long silent. The laity need no longer tolerate being marginalized by the hierarchy of the Church. VOTF members are the parish leaders - teachers, Eucharistic ministers, lectors, sacristans - the heart of the church. They are highly educated, faithful Catholics whose talents deserve to be used to the fullest in service of the Church. VOTF has inspired Catholics to organize parishioners into affiliates that can take positive action to promote healing in their parishes and faith communities. Today there are over 160 affiliated groups across the country, each numbering from 30 to over 600 members. VOTF has motivated parishioners to educate themselves about the rights of the laity as described in Church documents from Vatican II and Canon Law. These new insights have created a spirit of hope and renewal out of the ashes of shame. This moral awakening of the laity - and its attendant moral voice - has been heartening. It began one year ago when VOTF's pioneers stood up and said to their bishop and to the world, "We are the Church. We are the Body of Christ." I am proud to serve as president of Voice of the Faithful. It is a blessing to be in the company of so many wonderful people. One year old. One year young. Either way, we have come a long way. Either way, we have far to go. But you - we - are people of conviction and commitment who will not give up this fight. The Catholic Church matters to us. We are the Church. Let's get on with the work!
![]() Convocation ReflectionsOn a clear, brisk March 9 of 2002, twelve founding members of Voice of the Faithful took our new name, our red blazers and ties and a consensus-driven statement to the windy waterside of Boston's World Trade Center. There we would join over 3,000 Catholics from all corners of the Boston Archdiocese at convocation, a regular feature of archdiocesan governance held for parish leadership and representatives of parish life. The agenda for these convocations is usually set by the Cardinal and his advisors but in 2002, what would take place at this gathering was driven exclusively by the greatest crisis of the Catholic Church in its 500-year history in this country. Clergy and laity found themselves with one voice - a combination of outrage, pain, prayer and inquiry around the discovery of sexual abuse of children by clergy and what appeared at the time to be a system-wide cover-up. And speak we did. Representatives from the various parishes met with Cardinal Law in one space while the rest of us were divided into diocesan regions. Each region had its own room and its own facilitator who would record for the Cardinal what was said in words and tone. VOTF was only weeks old and we hadn't yet refined our mission statement and goals but according to many who were there, the St. John's contingent was remembered for its steady and articulate statements. Each of us wore something red that day - Svea Fraser's idea since red symbolizes the Holy Spirit. No one remembered to mention this to Jim Muller, the founder. Nonetheless, Jim showed up wearing a red tie and credited the Holy Spirit, Who, it turned out, prevailed throughout the day. March 9, 2002 was the first time VOTF left our birthing space at St. John the Evangelist in Wellesley Hills, MA and took our voices into the fray alongside fellow Catholics we might never have known otherwise. The blessings of that day linger as do memories some of the 13 of us share below. Representing VOTF that day were Kathi Aldridge, Paul Baier, Mary Calcaterra, Luise Dittrich, Svea Fraser, Andrea Johnson, Fr. Bill Kremmell, Jim Muller, Maura O'Brien, John O'Brien, Jeannette Post, Peggie Thorp and Susan Troy.
Convocation
Statement Voice of the Faithful,
|
Linda Atlas | Administrative Team |
Jean Boyle | Development Team |
Anne Moynihan - Coursey | Administrative Team |
Robert Davis | Technology Team |
Luise Cahill Dittrich | Communications Team |
Mike Emerton | Communications Team |
Bill Fallon | Development Team |
Eileen Powers Hespeler | Communications Team; Technology Team |
Ann Hynes | Development Team |
Jean Kelly | Development & Gift Processing |
Kate Kenney | Parish Voice Team |
Mary Ann Keyes | Parish Voice Team |
Steve Krueger | Executive Director |
Henrietta Maloney | Administrative Team |
Pat Merlo | Administrative Team |
Joe Milando | Technology Team |
Howard Miller | Administrative Team |
Marianne Miller | Administrative Team |
Mary Moran | Administrative Team |
Suzy Nauman | Parish Voice Team |
Ann Potts | Parish Voice Team |
Julie Rafferty | Development Team |
Martha Rowland | Development & Gift Processing |
Donna Salacuse | Development & Gift Processing |
Bev Spencer | Development & Gift Processing |
Margaret Sudbey | Development & Gift Processing |
Jim Sullivan | Administrative Team |
Peggie Thorp | Communications Team |
Rose Walsh | Administrative Team |
Dot Winslow | Administration Team |
Brueggemann presents a classic study of the prophet as a change agent in the face of a recalcitrant power structure that exploits the weak. He uses Moses as the paradigmatic prophet, and the pharaoh and his hierarchy as the governing power elite. To the extent that the Israelites were brought from freedom into slavery, the power elite have a need to suppress memory of truth and historical freedom and to ridicule hope. The elite replace Yaweh with the religion of static triumphalism and the politics of oppression and exploitation. Thus, Egypt organizes against history, which means everything must be frozen in the now, either in urgent now or an eternal now. Energizing memories or radical hope is held to be a curiosity and a threat. As the Egyptians gather around the static god of order who only guards the interests of the "haves," oppression cannot be far behind. Brueggemann reminds us that it is the aim of every totalitarian effort to stop the language of newness, and we are now learning that where such language stops we find our humanness diminished.
Moses offered an alternative consciousness of a God who answers the cries of the oppressed. This alternative consciousness is characterized by criticizing and energizing. Real criticism begins in the capacity to grieve. Grieving is the most visceral announcement that things are not right. Bringing criticism to public expression, in the primal scream of grieving, began a new history of the Jewish people in the Exodus. Energizing is launched through the prophet who retains the memory of things the way they used to be, and understands the power of language - the ability to speak in ways that evoke newness, amazement and, above all, hope. In Moses' case, the newness and hope sprang fresh from "the Word." All of these factors must precede the action it takes to effect change. Real change begins then, when the prophet imagines how things should be. Brueggemann offers three parts to the prophetic imagination: the use of symbols adequate to the horror of the situation, bringing public expression to the suppressed emotions that need visibility, and to speak metaphorically but concretely about the deathliness that hovers over them and gnaws within them.
There is much more to this book beyond this short review. Brueggemann shows how the prophetic imagination can transform the present in powerful and unexpected ways. He describes the prophetic imagination as a force which brings traditions together with the realities of our society.
Tom Smith is a deacon in the Archdiocese of Boston.
As the title suggests, the aim of this column is to take a second look at concepts and phrases we tend to think of as common currency. Exploring their root meanings, historical twists and turns in usage - and what we really understand by them - may get us out of some traditional but unnecessary dialectical boxes. For followers of the Word, it's ironic how often we let words get in our way. Our amazing gift of speech is mean for communicating truth - for conveying the realities of what is and the wonders of what can be. Yet we persist in using words to bludgeon and obfuscate, mislead and manipulate. (Who spins best, wins?)
Just as often, of course, there is no deceptive intent - we simply assume that everyone's understanding of a term is the same as ours, and forge ahead or take offense accordingly. Khrushchev's folk-quote about seeing one's opponents in their graves could have been read as a mocking "We will outlast you," but translated as a belligerent "We will bury you," and evoked near-lethal repercussions. Sociologists tell us that what is perceived as real is real in its effects. Leery of our tendency to argue in absolutes, theologians advise "never affirm, seldom deny, and always distinguish." Taking time for that Thomistic level of discernment doesn't always jibe well with contemporary impatience for action, but we're facing enough real dilemmas and grounds for debate without letting casual usage or unexamined concepts skew our dialog and growth. Unfortunately, Lewis Carroll's Humpty Dumpty "When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean," is not as unique as he might be. (His further insistence that the question is "which is to be master" deserves a follow-up column all to itself.)
Could goal-refinement and reconciliation both be enhanced by re-examining words and ideas we sometimes take for granted - or sometimes overload? To what extent, e.g.,
If we can reflect openly on some of our buzzwords and preconceptions - are willing in imitation of Christ to think radically, i.e., "at the root," rather than in conservative or liberal clichés - the process might help us grow in genuine humility, ability to listen, and evocative insights. We may keep finding more questions than answers, but that's O.K. too, as we place them in the care of the Omega, Whose grace and path call us forward.
Speaking of word roots, have you ever wondered about the derivation of "god" for the Deity? Clearly not from Deus, Theos, El or Yahweh, it has been traced through Old Norse to the ancient Sanskrit Ghuta: the One (to be) invoked, and Old Irish Guth: Voice (the One Who spoke). We could speculate that, like VOTF, it's all been about right relationships and conversation from the beginning, so let's pray we stay on that track. Please email your thoughts on the above and any other prospective for this column to saywhat@votf.com.
Welcome to the first in a series of questions, answers (and more questions!) from and for the members of Voice of the Faithful. We live in a torrential time of inquiry about the Church. We'd like to begin addressing some of the questions – about VOTF, about the Church, about the rights and responsibilities of the laity – being raised in your parish affiliates around the country. Our new monthly Q&A column will be dedicated to exploring and responding to the questions that come from the brothers and sisters "in the vineyard." Shocking as it sounds, we may not have all the answers. But we promise to seek answers by consulting Catholic tradition, teaching, history, experience and experts on your behalf.
This month's questions have been seeded by us. Next month we'd like the inquiry to spring from you. We welcome your questions, your quandaries and we look forward to an ongoing dialogue we hope educates and enlivens us as members of the Body of Christ.
Okay, the (planted) Question of the Month:
What kind of organization is Voice of the Faithful? Is it a lay association? Does it have or can it have any official standing in the church? The next issue of In the Vineyard will offer an answer that, we hope, will generate and feed the dialogue among us. So please begin to prioritize your list of questions and let’s tackle the answers together in the Christian tradition of inquiry, prayer and inclusive discussion. I welcome your thoughts at amurphy@votf.org. Please use Q & A in the subject line.
Collaboration Key at Celtic Night in Canton
Saint Gerard Majella Parish hosted "Celtic Night in Canton," in their church hall on Friday, February 21, 2003, from 8:00 to 11:00 PM. The event was a benefit for members of the Survivor's Network for those Abused by Priests (S.N.A.P.) Bill Gately, a former Canton resident and current NE co-coordinator for S.N.A.P. was on hand for the festivities. Bill was raised in St. Gerard's Parish and is a past president of the youth group at St. Gerard's
Celtic Night in Canton was a collaborative effort begun by Director of Music Ministry, Greg Pare. He was later joined by members of St. Gerard's Parish Voice and St. Gerard's Youth Ministry.
The strains of "Macushlah" and "Kathleen Mavourneen" as sung by Parish Voice member Frank Mahoney signaled the beginning of an evening of Irish festivities, and the "craic"* was off and running! The older members of the audience were thrilled to hear Frank's rendition of these favorites of long ago. Musical accompaniment was provided by "Mad To Go" with Mike Reynolds on the guitar and accordion, Bob Ryan, bass guitar/vocal and Brian Queadley, flutes and whistle.
It should come as no surprise that the highlight of the evening was the presentation of Irish Step Dancing by six lovely colleens of the O'Shea-Chaplin Academy of Irish Dance, Aisling Nally, Emily Ponte, Bridgit Ponte, Hillary Sussek and Maeve Sussek. A lively program of group and individual dances thrilled the audience as the young ladies showcased their beauty, talent and their traditional costumes in designs drawn from the Book of Kells.
Storytelling by Joe Keane from Co. Kerry by way of Medford and a marvelous selection of Gaelic songs sung by Mairin Keady of Co. Galway by way of Dorchester completed the evening's entertainment.
Additional attractions were Art of Ireland provided by Aisling Gallery of Hingham, a gift shop operated by Celtic Revival of Medford, and a wide selection of raffled gift baskets taken home by the lucky few. This writer's usual streak of luck prevailed and he went home with green and white balloons defined, as he usually is, by being filled with hot air.
Face-painting, bean-bag games and snow-globe making were some of the Youth Ministry sponsored activities enjoyed by the very young in spaces set aside especially for them.
Given attendance of over 130, and proceeds in excess of $1,500.00, the evening would have to be considered very much a success. A repeat performance next year would indeed be appropriate and appreciated. The gauntlet has been thrown down for other PVs to come forward with new, original ideas to keep the survivor support ball rolling.
Many parishioners and friends of St. Gerard's are to be congratulated for a job well done and a fine, innovative fundraising effort. They include:
Fr. Mac, Anne Semler, Claire Maranda, Jim and Mary Moran, Peggy Simons, Dave Keyo, Matt and Debbie Wellslager, Joe and Denise Thornton, Kathy and Bernie Donahoe, Maureen Hynes, Rosemarie Nally, Nora and Obie O'Brien, Stacia Hanlon, Paula Hanlon, Megan Keyo, Julie D'Agostino, Krista Cash, Erica Fletcher, Mary Rita Bustin, Sheldon Daly (South Region VOTF Coordinator) Debbie, Erin, Sean, and John Hynes
*craic - a good time
Watch for…
For MA area residents: James Carroll, author of American Requiem and Constantine's Sword and, more recently, a panelist at 2002 VOTF Convention, will be will be speaking at Governor Dummer Academy Performing Arts Center, Byfield, MA on Sunday, April 6 at7pm. Event is open to Public. Please contact the Academy for more details. Thanks to Mo Donovan of the VOTF Seacoast Affiliate, MA for passing this along.
For MA area residents: On Friday evening, March 21, 2003, at 7:15, Mary Jane England, MD, President of Regis College, will discuss the Commission for the Protection of Children in the Archdiocese of Boston at St. Elizabeth Seton's Church Hall, North Falmouth. All are welcome. Call for directions or further information - 508-563-5217.
For CT area residents: Friday, March 28 - Sunday, March 30, 2003, Yale University. Two-day conference exploring the challenges & opportunities facing the church in our time. VOTF president Jim Post a panelist on Saturday with Kathleen McChesney from the Office of Child and Youth Protection, USCCB. For registration and other information, visit http://www.yale.edu/stm/programs/govInfo.html
Major Regional Conference - Metro New York Survivors Support Conference co-sponsored by VOTF Greenwich, CT and Survivors First. Saturday, March 22, 1-5 pm, Christ Church, 254 E. Putnam Avenue, Greenwich, CT. Contact: Tom Malarkey at tomalark@aol.com or call 914-946-7315; Anne Barrett Doyle at barrett.doyle@attbi.com or call 781-944-7010
New England Tri-State GOAL #1 Forum co-sponsored by VOTF-NH, VOTF-ME and VOTF National Survivor Support Working Groups. The Tri State Meeting is at St. Thomas More Church in Durham, NH on March 29, 1-5 p.m. Bear left in front of the church and there is a parking lot 50 yards on the right. For details, contact Andrea Johnson at andreajohnson@attbi.com or call 781-237-2417.
Conference, Boston, MA - Taking Action to Prevent Child Sexual Abuse: Strategies for YOUR Community. Saturday, April 5, 8:30am-5pm, John Hancock Conference Center, Boston, MA. VOTF is a partnership member of the Massachusetts Child Sexual Abuse Prevention Partnership, which has organized this conference. See additional details under Protecting Our Children or visit our Web site at www.votf.org. Additional info available at www.masskids.org.
In the Boston, MA Archdiocese, VOTF members will join other groups for a peace-filled "Silent Watch" that will mark the sorrow felt by so many on behalf of the survivors. Organizers have also spoken of their hope for a just honesty in acts of repentance. The watch will take place at the Chancery, the seat of the Boston archdiocese, from noon to 3 p.m. throughout the forty days of Lent. Other affiliates around the country are planning similar actions. If you are interested in signing up for a day, please contact Andrea Johnson (Survivors Support working group in Wellesley) at andreajohnson@attbi.com.
VOTF's magnificent logo was designed by Healys' Graphic Ark. Please visit their Web site, http://www.healysgraphicark.com/VOTFlogo.html, where you can purchase many items bearing the VOTF symbol.